Yet whether this is the case depends not only on differences in family structures by socioeconomic background, but also on the strength of the effects of these family structures on the outcomes in question; if the effects are nil or weak, it does not matter who lives in which kind of family.
Increasing adoption of advanced methods to control for unmeasured variables improves our understanding of the consequences of family change. This means that where there are two different theories or ideas or stories about what has happened, there is no requirement to reject one, but instead to see both as two sides of the one coin.
Family dynamics theory
The first open question that in our view requires more attention regards the effects of these other family transitions and forms, namely the number of transitions, stepfamilies, and joint residential custody after parental separation Sect. Instead, the results imply that whether this happens or not is contingent on the strength of these effects and on whether they are similar across groups. Social Forces, 93 2 , — Even though growth-curve models enable analysis of how effects develop, they are not immune to confounding from unmeasured variables that can affect both the initial level of well-being and its development over time McLanahan et al. Family systems theory, in comparison, views problems in a more circular manner, using what is called a 'systemic perspective'. If the above and other conditions for making causal claims are met, which effects do they inform us about? There is a long-standing debate that concerns whether associations between family types and child outcomes reflect causal effects, or whether they are confounded by unmeasured variables. In addition, we engage in a related but much smaller discussion of what causal questions the different methods can be used to answer cf. Journal of Marriage and Family, 62 4 , —
All families have some helpful and some unhelpful dynamics. Reasons for the poorer performance of children with stepparents include the added complexity in family relationships that is often introduced by the presence of a stepparent.
Their behaviour may be in response to their unconscious anxiety about family breakdown. This has made SFE a popular method, not least in Europe.
The sibling who did not experience the parental separation is always the older one, and her grades are used to infer about the counterfactual grades of her younger sibling, had she not experienced the parental separation. We pay attention to what effects the methods can estimate, in addition to assessing which unobserved variables the different methods adjust for. Dunn Eds. Each of the subsequent articles in this Special Issue contributes to these issues. Social Forces, 73 3 , — Better recognition of these differences can contribute to theory-building and methodological advancement and help in formulating advice to parents, family counselors, and policy makers. When choosing the appropriate variables or designs, one should decide whether one is interested in the effects of the separation event or the exposure to the whole separation process. Most Recent About the Author This article was written by a professional writer, copy edited and fact checked through a multi-point auditing system, in efforts to ensure our readers only receive the best information. In general, they give more nuance to the overall association between growing up with both biological parents and child outcomes. When talking to a young person about their family dynamics, it is important to keep in mind that other family members may hold different perspectives and interpretations of events and behaviours. This approach facilitates change and growth by building self-confidence, optimism, motivation and a sense of empowerment. Where possible, use a strengths-based approach when exploring family dynamics, and identify strengths or ways a pattern serves those involved. Indeed, children in stepfamilies can even have lower psychological well-being and educational achievement than children living with a single mother Amato ; Biblarz and Raftery ; Thomson et al.
Life-table representations of family dynamics in the 21st century. This discussion highlights the importance of thinking about methodological choices and interpretations of the results in light of the underlying theoretical model of parental separation.
Family dynamics essay
Ascribed characteristics A family's attitude towards a young person has an important influence on their self-identity and self-worth. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press. For an SFE analysis, one needs data on multiple siblings, some of whom experienced the parental separation before age 15 whereas others did not. This can lead to ambiguity in roles and to conflict in the family Thomson et al. The most consistent family demographic finding is that children whose parents divorced are more likely to divorce themselves as adults e. Others claim that specific family forms and movements between them do matter beyond general family instability Magnuson and Berger ; Lee and McLanahan Name rules that govern behaviors and interactions within a family. Life-table representations of family dynamics in the 21st century.
based on 49 review